Download CIMA's pre-seen from the CGMA Study Hub and read it alongside this summary.
The Tendra Tents pre-seen gives more costing detail than most: a budget for each of its nine tent models, a full standard cost card for one of them and six short notes on how standards and budgets are set. This article reads that material as a Finance Officer would. It sits beside our main Tendra Tents article, and the figures are on our case study page with their pages. Download the pre-seen from the CGMA Study Hub and keep it open as you read.
What the cost card says
The example cost card is for Explorer Solo, a lightweight tent for one or two people. Per tent:
- Materials: T$121.50. Tent fabric, floor fabric, mesh panels and poles each have a standard quantity and price; other materials and packaging are given as amounts.
- Direct labour: T$29.20. 0.16 hours in Cutting, 0.60 in Sewing, 0.60 in Assembly & Testing and 0.10 in Packing, all at T$20 an hour: 1.46 hours in total on our addition.
- Variable overhead: T$11.65, absorbed at a different rate per labour hour in each department, from T$3.61 in Assembly & Testing to T$15.75 in Cutting.
- Fixed overhead: T$46.58, again at departmental rates per labour hour, from T$14.44 in Assembly & Testing to T$62.99 in Cutting.
That makes T$208.93 a tent, which matches the unit cost the budget uses for Explorer Solo.
Two things stand out. Materials are well over half the cost, so material prices and usage move the margin more than anything else. And fixed overhead is larger than labour itself: for every T$1 of labour, about T$1.60 of fixed overhead is absorbed on top.
The six notes, and what each one does
The notes under the cost card are short, but each one changes how you read the numbers.
1. Standards are reviewed once a year. The pre-seen's industry page says nylon, polyester and aluminium are rising in price, and those are the materials Tendra's fabrics, mesh and poles are made of. Our reading: between reviews, rising prices would show up as adverse material price variances that nobody on the shop floor caused. A good answer separates a planning variance (the standard is out of date) from an operational one (someone paid more than they had to).
2. Normal losses are in the standard. The standard quantity already allows for routine waste, such as offcuts from laser cutting. So an adverse usage variance points to abnormal waste: a poor batch of fabric, a machine set up wrongly, a new pattern that nests badly. Ask what changed.
3. Overtime premium is variable overhead, and no idle time is budgeted. This is the note most likely to catch you out. If production works overtime, the basic hours go to direct labour but the premium lands in variable overhead, so it shows as a variable overhead expenditure variance rather than a labour rate variance. With no idle time in the standard, any time spent waiting for materials or a broken machine appears as an adverse labour efficiency variance, unless idle time is recorded separately. Our reading: a trigger with idle time, overtime or both would test whether you put each cost in the right place.
4. Overheads are absorbed on labour hours, by cost centre. Overheads are allocated and apportioned to the four production departments, and each has its own variable and fixed rate. The pre-seen doesn't show how the support departments (Product Development, Raw Materials, Maintenance) are shared out. Cutting has the highest rates by far and uses little labour time per tent. The pre-seen doesn't say why, but laser cutting machines and their software suggest a department whose costs are driven by machines, not people. Our reading: absorbing machine-driven cost on labour hours could distort what each model appears to cost, which opens the door to a task on machine hours or activity-based costing.
5. Standard selling prices allow for planned discounts and promotions. The price in the budget is already net of the expected deals. A sales price variance therefore measures discounting beyond the plan, not discounting as such.
6. Budgets are incremental, with limited involvement from operational managers. Last year's figures plus an adjustment, set largely by senior people. Quick and cheap, but it can carry old inefficiencies forward, and managers who had little say may not feel the targets are theirs. Our reading: tasks on participation, budgetary slack, zero-based or rolling budgets, and whether a target is realistic all fit here.
Margins by model
The budget gives revenue, cost of sales and gross profit for each of the nine models. Gross margins run:
- Essential: Solo 5.4%, Duo 26.4%, Family 30.7%.
- Explorer: Solo 16.6%, Duo 28.8%, Family 38.5%.
- Elite: Compact 32.4%, Trek 36.4%, Basecamp 40.1%.
Within every range, the bigger the tent, the better the margin. The smallest tent in each range is the weakest, and Essential Solo is far below the rest: T$58k of gross profit on 7,500 tents.
Before anyone suggests dropping it, work out the contribution. Its standard cost is T$135.56: materials T$66.50, labour T$22.80, variable overhead T$9.25 and fixed overhead T$37.01. Its revenue averages about T$143 a tent across both channels. Treating materials, labour and variable overhead as variable, our rough contribution is about T$45 a tent, or around T$336k across the budget. Most of the T$37 of fixed overhead would stay if the model went, and would be spread over the other tents. A drop decision also needs the non-financial side: the Solo may be how many campers come to the brand.
The channel layer
Every model has a website price and a lower retailer price. On our arithmetic the retailer price is 85% of the website price across the Essential range, 82% across Explorer and 80% across Elite. Retailers also take a growing share as you move up: 30% of Essential tents, 40% of Explorer and 50% of Elite.
The cost per tent is the same whichever channel it goes through, so the whole price gap comes off the margin. But the website carries costs the cost card doesn't: courier delivery, returns, the AI shopping tools. The budget stops at gross profit, so a fair channel comparison needs those costs too. If a task asks which channel is more profitable, say what you would need to know.
Reading a variance at Tendra
Put it together and a sound variance answer here does four things:
- Names the variance and its size, in T$, and says whether it is adverse or favourable.
- Puts it in the right place. Overtime premium in variable overhead; idle time in labour efficiency unless recorded separately; normal waste already in the standard.
- Gives a likely cause from the case: a supplier change, rising material prices since the annual review, a new machine, a sewing team short of skilled technicians.
- Says what to do, and who should do it: the Head of Cutting, the Head of Raw Materials, Rafael Ortega, or the Head of Finance.
A quick self-test
- If Sewing works overtime for a month, where does the premium go, and which variance shows it?
- Why might an adverse material price variance not be the buyer's fault?
- Why would dropping Essential Solo reduce profit, on the budget figures?
- What would change if overheads in Cutting were absorbed on machine hours?
- What could an incremental budget hide, and who might notice?
If you can answer those using Tendra's own numbers, you are well placed for costing and budget triggers in this case. For the wider picture, go back to our main Tendra Tents article or see how answers are marked on our method page.