This pre-seen was for an earlier sitting. Sitting MCS next? Read our summary of the current Wuudbreak pre-seen.
This pre-seen was for the May and August 2026 MCS exams, which have now passed. For the current MCS case, see our Wuudbreak pre-seen article and the Wuudbreak case study.
This is our own summary of the Cartn pre-seen for the CIMA Management Case Study (MCS). If you want to use it for practice, download CIMA's pre-seen from the CGMA Study Hub and read it in full alongside this summary.
The company in brief
Cartn is a quoted food packaging manufacturer based in Harrland, a fictional country that uses the H$ and requires IFRS. It was founded in 1960 by engineers and listed on the Harrlandian Stock Exchange in 1978. It is one of the six largest makers of cartons and tubs in the world, with factories in many countries, and it holds many patents for design features.
Cartn earns money in two ways:
- Manufacturing. Cartons for milk, milk substitutes and fruit juice, and tubs for products such as yoghurt and ice cream. Cartons leave the factory as printed rolls of laminated material plus separate caps, and the customer's own machinery folds and seals them. Tubs are shipped preformed, with lids supplied separately. Everything comes in standard sizes.
- Consultancy. Cartn's engineers design packaging systems that fit a client's production line. Cartn advises only. It recommends specific equipment for the client to buy, and provides plans for installation, but it neither supplies nor installs the machines.
The two sides are meant to help each other. A consultancy client may go on to buy Cartn's packaging, and customers who succeed order more.
The pre-seen also spends a long time on food packaging itself: primary, secondary and tertiary packaging, the trade-offs between rigid, flexible and semi-rigid containers, and what food manufacturers weigh up when they choose. Read that section carefully. It tells you what Cartn's customers care about: safety, shelf life, cost, appearance, regulation and sustainability.
Your role
You are a financial manager at Cartn's head office, reporting to the senior financial manager, who reports to the Finance Director. Your work is mainly management accounting.
MCS moves you up from the operational level. You are no longer explaining a single variance to a supervisor. You are helping other managers make medium-term decisions about investments, pricing, performance measures, financing and change. Your answers need to be analytical, and they also need to show you understand the people affected.
The syllabus here is E2, P2 and F2: investment appraisal, costing and pricing, performance measurement, managing projects and change, financing, group reporting and sustainability reporting.
Key figures to know
We keep numbers in this summary to a minimum: the figures belong in CIMA's document, not in our notes. A few headline points are worth holding in your head:
- Group revenue is a little over H$1.2 billion, up on the year before, and operating profit rose more strongly.
- Cartn employs about 23,000 people in 27 factories, plus around 800 design and technical staff in its consultancy offices.
- Average emissions per carton have fallen to 24.0 g CO2e, from 35.0 g in 2015.
Build your own one-page figures sheet from the statements. For this business, the useful working is likely to be:
- Gross and operating margins for both years, and why they moved.
- Working capital: inventory, receivables and payables against revenue, and the cash balance.
- Borrowing against equity, and the dividend against the year's profit.
- The currency reserve and exchange differences, which point to overseas operations.
- The same ratios for Valboxx, a rival that only manufactures. Valboxx has higher revenue and a higher operating profit than Cartn, without any consultancy business.
That last comparison matters. If you know where Cartn sits against Valboxx before you start, you can judge any new figure quickly.
Themes the pre-seen opened up
The pre-seen did not say what the unseen material would contain. What we can do is list the themes it opened up for the two sittings, so you can check your practice covers enough ground:
- Recycling versus repurposing. Cartn's cartons are made from bonded layers of paperboard, aluminium and plastic, which makes them hard to recycle. A news article in the pre-seen separates true recycling from repurposing. That opens up honest sustainability claims and the evidence behind them.
- Sustainability reporting and governance. The Product Development Director oversees sustainability strategy, a committee of senior managers prepares and interprets reports, and department heads must explain missed targets. Think about how targets are set, measured and reported, and how managers react to them.
- New product investment. Cartn says it is working on products that are easier to recycle, and the pre-seen discusses design engineers and prototypes. A new carton or material is a natural setting for NPV, payback, sensitivity and the non-financial factors.
- Consultancy pricing and projects. Fees are based on estimated time and engineer seniority, and overruns fall on the client or on Cartn depending on the cause. That opens up project management, cost control, pricing decisions and disputes with clients.
- Two businesses under one roof. How should consultancy be judged: on its own profit, or on the packaging sales it brings in? Performance measures and how central costs are shared could follow.
- The rival's results. Valboxx focuses on manufacturing only. Its figures invite comparison, and the question of what they really tell Cartn.
- Overseas operations. Factories and offices in several countries mean currency risk, translation of foreign results in the group accounts, and transfer pricing between group companies.
- Working capital. Customers order often so they hold little stock themselves. The pre-seen doesn't draw the link, but our reading is that this puts pressure on Cartn's own inventory and delivery.
- Staff and change. Cartn invests heavily in training. Any new process, product or system raises questions about change, resistance and keeping skilled people.
- Financing. Any large investment could be funded from cash, borrowing or equity, each with a different effect on the statements and on risk.
Use the list to guide your revision, not to write answers in advance. The unseen trigger is the reason each task exists, and answers that ignore it score poorly.
Using Cartn for practice
If you work through Cartn as practice before a later sitting, these steps help.
Read the pre-seen twice. First for the story, then as a financial manager at head office. On the second read, mark every place where a decision would affect customers, consultancy clients or staff.
Say the business model in one sentence. For example: "Cartn makes printed cartons and tubs for food and drink companies, and sells engineering advice that helps clients set up lines to use them." If you can say that, you can test any idea in the exam against it.
Learn the packaging background. Many tasks may turn on a customer's needs. Knowing why a juice carton needs an aluminium layer, or why a product might skip secondary packaging, helps you write about Cartn rather than about packaging in general.
Revise E2, P2 and F2 through Cartn. An NPV is easier to remember as an NPV on a recyclable carton. A balanced scorecard makes more sense with emissions, on-time delivery and consultancy hours in it.
Practise writing for managers. At MCS you often write to someone with a view already. Practise explaining the finance clearly while showing you understand their position.
Do timed practice early and sit full mocks. The exam rewards writing well under time pressure, and that only improves with practice. Three hours of tasks in exam order shows you where your time goes.
Review every answer honestly. Did you answer the verb, use the new information, tie each point to Cartn, consider the people involved and recommend where asked? Our method page explains how answers are judged.
Practise with timed tasks
We don't have practice tasks set in Cartn. The skills the exam rewards are the same for every case, though: reading a trigger, applying it to the business and advising under time pressure. Timed practice on the current MCS case builds exactly those skills. See our Management Case Study page to start.