Skip to content

Wuudbreak against Vannpark: reading the competitor's results

Vannpark makes more profit than Wuudbreak on less revenue. What the two sets of results show, what they can't, and how to use them in an MCS answer.

MCSPre-seen insights

Download CIMA's pre-seen from the CGMA Study Hub and read it alongside this summary.

The Wuudbreak pre-seen gives you two sets of accounts: Wuudbreak's own and those of Vannpark, a competitor that runs caravan parks on Norrland's coast. Both groups have a 30 September year end, both report in N$, and both show two years. That makes the comparison unusually clean, and it gives MCS a ready-made subject for performance measurement, cost management and financial reporting tasks.

This article works through the comparison and, just as importantly, its limits. Download CIMA's pre-seen from the CGMA Study Hub and keep pages 15 to 19 open as you read. Every figure, with its page and our ratios for both companies, is on our Wuudbreak case study page, and the wider themes are in our main Wuudbreak article.

Two different businesses

Before any ratio, be clear about what each company sells.

  • Wuudbreak runs nine forest parks beside lakes. Guests stay in apartments for three or four nights, pay in full when they book, and spend on site by wristband on paid activities and in Wuudbreak's own supermarkets. The food courts are run by franchisees, who keep their takings and pay Wuudbreak rent and charges.
  • Vannpark runs 11 caravan parks, all on the coast. Most guests book a week. Its parks have restaurants serving meals all day, and every caravan has self-catering facilities.

The pre-seen describes caravan parks in general as relatively inexpensive holidays, and Wuudbreak's as quite expensive. So the two are competing for some of the same households with quite different offers. Keep that in mind: the same ratio can mean different things in the two models.

The headline gap

Year to 30 September 2026 Wuudbreak Vannpark
Revenue N$843.7m N$776.2m
Gross profit N$601.9m N$574.4m
Administrative expenses N$234.0m N$73.0m
Operating profit N$367.9m N$501.4m
Profit for the year N$233.9m N$351.8m

Vannpark earns N$67.5m less revenue but N$133.5m more operating profit. Its operating margin is 64.6% against Wuudbreak's 43.6%.

Work down the statement and the gap is not at gross profit level. Gross margins are 74.0% at Vannpark and 71.3% at Wuudbreak, and Wuudbreak's cost of sales actually fell in the year, from N$250.1m to N$241.8m, while its revenue rose 4.5%. The difference is in administrative expenses: Wuudbreak's are about 27.7% of revenue, Vannpark's about 9.4%. And Wuudbreak's grew 8.8% in the year, almost twice as fast as its revenue, while Vannpark's barely moved.

What could explain it

The pre-seen doesn't break down either company's administrative expenses, so anything here is our reading, not a fact. That is exactly the position you would be in during the exam, and a good answer says so. Possible explanations worth testing:

  • Classification. Companies decide which costs go in cost of sales and which in administration. If Wuudbreak puts park staff, cleaning or forestry teams in administration and Vannpark puts similar costs in cost of sales, the gap partly reflects a policy choice, not efficiency.
  • What each company does. Wuudbreak's parks carry wildlife specialists, park guides, indoor and outdoor activities, central areas watched by CCTV, and forestry management. A coastal caravan park may simply need less of that.
  • Head office. Wuudbreak has a head office with a finance team with a Senior Financial Manager and at least one financial manager below him. How large it is, and how its costs are shared out, the pre-seen doesn't say.
  • Growth in the year. An 8.8% rise needs explaining on its own. It could be pay, new roles, systems work or one-off costs.

In an answer, the strongest move is to name what you would check: a breakdown of administrative expenses by type and by park, the accounting policy for classifying costs, and head office headcount.

Per park

Dividing by the number of parks gives a different angle.

Per park, 2026 Wuudbreak Vannpark
Revenue N$93.7m N$70.6m
Operating profit N$40.9m N$45.6m
Property, plant and equipment N$335.0m N$223.9m

Each Wuudbreak park brings in more revenue but less profit, and ties up far more in property, plant and equipment. Return on capital employed (operating profit over equity plus loans) is 12.2% at Wuudbreak and 21.1% at Vannpark, and asset turnover is 0.28 against 0.33.

Per-park figures are averages. The pre-seen gives no results by park and no park sizes, so you can't tell whether some Wuudbreak parks are far more profitable than others. If the unseen gives park-level figures, that is the time to compare them.

Financing and payouts

The two groups fund themselves differently.

  • Loans. Wuudbreak has N$1,003.8m of loans, unchanged across both years; Vannpark has N$550.0m, also unchanged. Gearing (loans over loans plus equity) is 33.3% against 23.1%.
  • Interest. Finance costs were flat at N$60.2m and N$38.5m, an implied rate of about 6.0% for Wuudbreak and 7.0% for Vannpark. Interest cover is 6.1 times against 13.0.
  • Dividends. Wuudbreak paid N$72.7m, about 31% of its profit. Vannpark paid N$342.9m, about 97.5% of its profit.
  • Cash. Wuudbreak's bank balance rose from N$45.8m to N$93.3m. Vannpark's fell from N$16.8m to N$15.2m.

Our reading: Wuudbreak keeps more of its profit, holds more debt and is building cash. That opens financing questions in both directions: whether to repay loans, pay more out, or use the cash for new capacity. The pre-seen gives no cash flow statement, so you can't see how much went on new assets; property, plant and equipment rose by N$103.4m, but that figure is after depreciation, which isn't shown.

Working capital tells you about the model

Two working capital figures are worth a closer look.

  • Receivables. Wuudbreak's are N$17.9m, about eight days of revenue. Vannpark's are N$124.2m, about 58 days. Wuudbreak's guests pay in full straight after booking, which fits the low figure. The pre-seen doesn't say when Vannpark's guests pay, so a large receivables balance suggests they don't all pay up front, but that is an inference.
  • Inventory. Vannpark holds N$38.8m against Wuudbreak's N$6.2m. Our reading is that Vannpark's restaurants need stock that Wuudbreak's franchised food courts don't, though the pre-seen doesn't say who runs Vannpark's restaurants.

Both current ratios are well below 1 (0.29 and 0.48). For Wuudbreak, some of the N$334.1m of trade and other payables is probably money paid for stays after the year end, which is a liability under IFRS 15 until the stay is delivered. Read a low current ratio here as part of a prepaid model before calling it a liquidity problem.

The limits of the comparison

A strong MCS answer always states what a comparison can't prove. Here:

  • One year, two years at most. Trends need longer.
  • Different models. Week-long coastal caravan breaks and short forest apartment breaks have different cost structures.
  • Classification and policy. Cost of sales against administration, depreciation lives and asset valuations may differ.
  • Missing measures. The pre-seen gives Wuudbreak's occupancy, repeat guests and satisfaction, but nothing similar for Vannpark.
  • Group accounts. Both are groups. Wuudbreak's intangible assets, N$286.1m, are unchanged; the pre-seen doesn't say what they are or what the group's subsidiaries do.

Using it in the exam

If a task gives you new figures for either company, set them against these baselines straight away. If it asks you to evaluate performance, compare on the same basis, explain the likely causes, and then say what you would need to know. If it asks whether Wuudbreak should cut costs to match Vannpark, remember what the extra cost may be buying: the guides, wildlife teams, activities and cleanliness that guests praise, and the repeat bookings that follow.

More insights