Download CIMA's pre-seen from the CGMA Study Hub and read it alongside this summary.
The SCS pre-seen gives two years of financial statements for Vennlisk and for Ringcoll, its closest competitor. This article sets them side by side and says what we read into the gap. Download CIMA's pre-seen from the CGMA Study Hub and check every number against it; page numbers below are the pages of CIMA's PDF. For the wider picture, start with our main Vennlisk article.
Who Ringcoll is
The pre-seen says Westland has seven major inbound call centre providers, which compete with each other and with overseas centres serving Westland callers (p20). Ringcoll is the closest of them: based in Westland, quoted, specialising in inbound calls, and often bidding for the same contracts as Vennlisk (p20). Both groups have a 30 September year end and report in W$ millions, which makes the comparison clean.
The pre-seen names no other major provider. A rival other than Ringcoll in an exam task would be new information.
Two businesses of similar size, heading in opposite directions
| Year to 30 September 2026 | Vennlisk | Ringcoll |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue | W$12,370.0m | W$10,514.5m |
| Revenue growth | 6.4% | 9.9% |
| Gross margin | 12.3% (was 11.4%) | 14.4% (was 17.2%) |
| Operating profit | W$1,451.0m | W$1,449.5m |
| Operating margin | 11.7% (was 10.8%) | 13.8% (was 16.6%) |
| Return on capital employed | 10.6% | 15.3% |
Sources: pp18 and 20. Ratios are ours.
The striking line is operating profit: the two are almost identical, at about W$1.45bn each. They got there from opposite directions. Vennlisk's operating profit rose by about 16% as its cost of sales grew more slowly than its revenue (5.3% against 6.4%). Ringcoll's fell by about 9%, because its cost of sales grew faster than its revenue (13.6% against 9.9%).
Our reading: Ringcoll is winning work but earning less on it. One explanation is that it is pricing low to win contracts; another is that its costs, such as pay, rose sharply. The pre-seen doesn't say which. In an exam answer, name the possibilities and say what you would want to know, rather than asserting a cause.
Where the gap really is: below operating profit
| Year to 30 September 2026 | Vennlisk | Ringcoll |
|---|---|---|
| Borrowings | W$5,460.0m | W$1,800.0m |
| Finance costs | W$436.8m | W$144.0m |
| Interest cover | 3.3 times | 10.1 times |
| Gearing (debt ÷ debt plus equity) | 39.8% | 19.0% |
| Profit for the year | W$770.8m | W$1,005.2m |
| Dividends paid | W$509.6m | W$374.9m |
| Dividend payout | 66.1% | 37.3% |
| Bank balance | W$986.1m | W$297.6m |
Sources: pp18–21. Ratios are ours.
Same operating profit, very different profit for the year. Vennlisk's borrowings are three times Ringcoll's, so its finance costs take about W$293m more out of the same operating profit. Both groups' finance costs work out at 8.0% of borrowings, and both kept borrowings and finance costs unchanged across the two years. Our reading is that both have fixed-rate debt that wasn't repaid in the year; the pre-seen gives no terms, maturity dates or covenants, so treat that as inference.
Vennlisk then paid out two-thirds of its smaller profit as dividends. Its dividend is covered about 1.5 times; Ringcoll's about 2.7 times. Vennlisk kept about W$261m of the year's profit in the business; Ringcoll kept about W$630m.
What the balance sheets add
- Intangible assets. Vennlisk's goodwill (W$6,274.0m) and other intangibles (W$2,249.0m) together exceed its total equity of W$8,253.1m (p19). Its tangible net assets are therefore negative. Ringcoll's intangibles are about three-quarters of its equity (p21). Vennlisk's goodwill fits its history of growth through acquisitions (p11).
- Physical assets. Vennlisk's property, plant and equipment rose; Ringcoll's fell by about 10% while its other intangible assets rose (pp19, 21). Our reading: that could point to Ringcoll spending on software rather than buildings, but the pre-seen doesn't say.
- Working capital. Vennlisk's receivable days were steady at about 42. Ringcoll's rose from about 30 to 38, and its trade payables roughly halved, from W$649.4m to W$332.8m (p21). Paying suppliers faster while collecting from clients more slowly would normally drain cash, yet Ringcoll's bank balance rose slightly. Without cash flow statements, we can't explain it, and nor can you in the exam: flag it as something to investigate.
Share of the market
The seven majors together earned W$38bn in the year to 31 December 2025 (p9). Set against that, Vennlisk's revenue for its year to 30 September 2025 is about 31% and Ringcoll's about 25%: together, more than half of what the seven earned. The periods differ by a quarter, so these are approximate. The same chart forecasts strong growth for the industry every year to 2033 (p9). If that forecast is right, both groups grew more slowly than the market last year. Our reading is that this makes growth, and who captures it, a fair question for the board.
What it could mean for Vennlisk's choices
These are our readings, not facts from the pre-seen:
- Bidding. If Vennlisk and Ringcoll bid for the same contract, Ringcoll can afford to bid lower for longer. Vennlisk's answer, by the pre-seen's account, is quality (p27); a task could test whether quality can justify a higher price.
- Investment. Funding an AI programme or an acquisition from more debt looks hard with interest cover of 3.3 times and negative tangible net assets. Cutting the dividend, issuing shares or raising money against the five call centres it owns (p11) are the obvious alternatives, each with costs.
- Valuation. If a trigger asks you to value Ringcoll, or a bidder approaches Vennlisk, remember the pre-seen gives no share count for either group and no share price for Ringcoll. State your assumptions. Vennlisk's beta of 0.48 (p22) is a starting point for its cost of equity, but you would still need a risk-free rate and a market premium from the unseen.
- Reading a rival. Ringcoll's falling margin is a warning as well as an opportunity. If the whole market is under price pressure, Vennlisk's improving margin may not last.
How to use this in the exam
Don't recite ratios. Use one or two to support a judgement: "Ringcoll's borrowing is a third of ours, so it can afford to bid lower; we should compete on the service measures this client values rather than match its price." Keep the scale in mind: against operating profit of about W$1.45bn, a contract worth W$100m of profit is significant, and a bid that costs W$2bn would need new funding.
The figures pack on our Vennlisk case study page has every figure above with its page, and the full list of ratios for both groups. For how the themes fit together, see our main Vennlisk article.