Download CIMA's pre-seen from the CGMA Study Hub and read it alongside this summary.
SCS tasks often put you in front of the board or one of its committees. The Vennlisk pre-seen gives a detailed picture of both, and of the principal risks the board reports. This article sets out what it says and then the questions we think it raises. Download CIMA's pre-seen from the CGMA Study Hub and read pages 13 to 17 alongside this; page numbers are the pages of CIMA's PDF. For the case as a whole, see our main Vennlisk article.
Who is on the board
| Director | Role | Background | On the board since |
|---|---|---|---|
| Murat Mutlu | Non-Executive Chair | Contract lawyer; senior roles at a large law firm, including managing partner | 2023 |
| Chen Yue | Chief Executive Officer | Electronic engineer in telecoms; joined Vennlisk in 2011 | 2018 (CEO from 2023) |
| Farrukh Jamil | Human Resources Director | HR director at a major quoted car manufacturer | 2023 |
| Dr Maria Chandler | Operations Director | Doctorate in queuing theory for customer service; strategic planning at Westland Telecommunications | Joined 2021 |
| Tshepo Batane | Chief Financial Officer | Qualified accountant; finance roles in retail and service businesses; joined in 2018 | CFO from 2023 |
| Noor Ebbini | Marketing Director | Joined as a management trainee | 2024 |
| Kyle Keimer | Senior Independent Director | Administrator in Westland's health service; led efficiency measures | 2025 |
| Mirjana Churlin | Independent non-executive | Mathematics teacher, headteacher, schools inspector | 2024 |
| Alaor Leite | Independent non-executive | Finance director of a major quoted manufacturer | 2025 |
Sources: pp13–15.
Who does what. The HR Director covers recruitment, retention, training, and health and safety. The Operations Director covers call centre operations, software development and sustainability. The CFO covers financial reporting, management accounting and treasury. The Marketing Director covers marketing, client liaison and public relations (p15).
Committees. Each of the four committees has three of the four non-executives (p16):
- Audit: Murat Mutlu, Kyle Keimer, Mirjana Churlin.
- Risk and sustainability: Murat Mutlu, Mirjana Churlin, Alaor Leite.
- Remuneration: Kyle Keimer, Mirjana Churlin, Alaor Leite.
- Nomination: Murat Mutlu, Kyle Keimer, Alaor Leite.
The Chief Internal Auditor, who isn't named, reports to the convener of the Audit Committee (p16). The pre-seen doesn't say who the convener is.
The governance questions we read into it
These are our readings. The pre-seen doesn't say which governance code applies in Westland, so present them as questions for the board, not breaches.
- The chair sits on the audit committee. Many codes, including the UK's, expect the audit committee to be made up of independent non-executives and the chair of the board to stay off it. Here the chair is one of three members.
- The finance expert isn't on it. Alaor Leite, a former finance director of a quoted company, sits on every committee except audit. Codes commonly ask for at least one audit committee member with recent and relevant financial experience. The current members' backgrounds are law, health service administration and education.
- Balance of the board. There are five executives and three independent non-executives besides the chair. Many codes expect at least half the board, excluding the chair, to be independent.
- Recent change. The chair, chief executive, CFO and HR Director all took up their posts in 2023, and three non-executives have joined since 2024. The share price had peaked in 2022 and was falling (pp22, 27). The pre-seen doesn't connect the two, so any link is inference.
- Skills. No director's background is in AI or data. With AI under evaluation (p12), a task could ask how the board would oversee it.
- Sustainability oversight. The Risk and Sustainability Committee reports to the board, and the Operations Director has executive oversight of sustainability (p23). The same director runs the call centres, whose energy use, cooling and staff welfare the targets cover, which could raise a question about independent challenge.
The principal risks
The pre-seen lists five principal risks, each with its mitigation (p17). In our own words:
| Risk | How Vennlisk handles it |
|---|---|
| Service quality depends on keeping trained, experienced agents | Strong pay, and training and career development so agents don't need to move to rivals |
| Agents become demotivated or careless, hurting caller satisfaction and clients' reputations | All calls recorded; supervisors review samples, give feedback, listen live and can take over a call; voice menus take simple tasks so agents do more interesting work |
| Health and safety from long periods at workstations | Checks that agents take regular breaks |
| Privacy of client files, with the risk of reputational damage, security breaches and fraud | Extensive training in caller privacy and the law, with regular refreshers |
| Dependence on telecoms links, where breakdowns mean poor quality or lost service | Close working with telecoms providers, reporting problems in real time |
What the risk register leaves out
In our reading, the most useful observation for SCS is what isn't there. Every principal risk is operational or about people. Three threats raised elsewhere in the pre-seen are missing:
- Low-cost overseas competition, which a press report blames for the share price fall (p27).
- Technology change, including AI and chatbots (pp12, 26).
- Financial risk, with borrowings of W$5,460.0m against Ringcoll's W$1,800.0m and interest cover of about 3.3 times (pp18–21).
A task could ask whether the register matches the strategy, or what a strategic risk entry for one of these would look like: the risk, its owner, the board's appetite, the controls and how the board would know they work.
Are the controls as strong as they look?
Several mitigations rely on supervisors. A new agent's blog says each supervisor manages about 20 agents and works harder than they do for little more pay (p25). Our reading is that listening to samples, giving feedback and monitoring live calls across a team that size is demanding, so the control may be weaker in practice than on paper. The blog is one person's view, so use it as a signal, not proof.
The blog also says the system counts calls handled each day, and describes feeling pressed to rush callers (p25). The pre-seen's own section on metrics warns that short handle times can mean rushed and repeat calls (p8). That links the "demotivated agents" risk to how performance is measured, a natural area for a control or incentive task.
Privacy controls rest on training. Call recordings, which support quality control, are themselves personal data. If AI is introduced, both the privacy risk and the controls change.
How to use this in the exam
- Name the right person. Send an audit question to the Audit Committee, a sustainability question to the Risk and Sustainability Committee, a pay question to the Remuneration Committee.
- Use the reporting line. The Chief Internal Auditor reports to the audit committee's convener, which matters for any task on internal audit's independence.
- Tie risks to strategy. Show how a new risk in the trigger fits, or doesn't fit, the existing register.
- Recommend. Say what the board should change, who owns it and how progress will be reported.
For the figures behind the financial risk, see Vennlisk against Ringcoll and the figures pack on our Vennlisk case study page.