CIMA MCS · May & Aug 2026 · Variant 1
Cartn variant 1 debrief: packaging for next-day meal kits
Cartn has designed packaging that lets a customer, Luxsoup, send out boxes of fresh meal ingredients that arrive the next day. The exam follows the project from its fit with the business model, through risk and debt funding, to accounting for the development spending, seconding designers abroad and reporting the product.
Updated · Examiner's report pp199–203
- Tasks
- 4
- Sub-tasks
- 8
- Topics
- 8
- Pre-seen
- Cartn
Task 1
Trigger: Product Development warns that meeting Cartn's commitments to the customer will be costly, and the Board sets up a project team to manage the response.
(a) Evaluate60% of the task
Core activity A: Adding value- What it asked
- How consistent the proposal is with Cartn's business model.
- Stronger answers
- Thought about the parts of the business model against the nature of the product, for example Cartn's limited experience with some of the packaging components.
- Weaker answers
- Summarised the business model, which the reader already had, and so added little.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: All-inclusive trend: fit with our business model
(b) Recommend, stating reasons40% of the task
Core activity B: Implementing decisions- What it asked
- Whether the project team should start with the technical design problems or with recovering Cartn's investment.
- Stronger answers
- Picked one, set out the criteria behind the choice and justified it logically.
- Weaker answers
- Discussed both technical and commercial issues and never chose.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Who should run the treetop trail project?
Task 2
Trigger: A colleague's email flags risks with the new product, and the development work needs significant new funding.
(a) Recommend with reasons60% of the task
Core activity C: Performance and costs- What it asked
- Ways to mitigate the commodity price, product and contractual inadequacy risks the email raises.
- Stronger answers
- Gave realistic mitigations; those using TARA did well when each risk got a specific action that delivered the response the model points to.
- Weaker answers
- Described the risks in detail without mitigating them, or named TARA without saying how a risk would be avoided or transferred.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Summer risks: transfer, avoid, reduce or accept each one
(b) Identify and evaluate40% of the task
Core activity B: Implementing decisions- What it asked
- The features of borrowing that would affect its suitability for funding the development.
- Stronger answers
- Took features from study materials and adapted them to Cartn, for example that lenders want security, while development work creates intellectual property that is poor collateral.
- Weaker answers
- Generic features of debt, and some described equity as well, though the sub-task asked about borrowing alone.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: New park funding: loan or sale and leaseback?
Task 3
Trigger: The customer threatens to pull out of its agreement to buy the packaging, and expert designers may be seconded to an overseas consultancy office.
(a) Advise40% of the task
Core activity D: Measuring performance- What it asked
- The accounting implications for two financial years of the customer's threat to withdraw.
- Stronger answers
- Covered the current year's development spending in more detail and the issues for the next year's planned spending if Cartn goes ahead.
- Weaker answers
- Applied the intangibles standard (IAS 38) to the current year and stopped, or assumed the next year's spending happens whatever the customer decides.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Year-end advance payments: the correct accounting
(b) Identify and evaluate60% of the task
Core activity E: Stakeholders- What it asked
- The difficulties of measuring the opportunity cost of seconding the designers.
- Stronger answers
- Went into depth on the costs of pulling staff from projects elsewhere and the risk of demotivating staff sent abroad, even for a short time.
- Weaker answers
- Little detail on what makes the opportunity cost hard to measure.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Linen Services: why the new transfer price could cause dysfunctional decisions
Task 4
Trigger: Cartn plans to grow the product range and must report on it.
(a) Recommend with reasons60% of the task
Core activity D: Measuring performance- What it asked
- Balanced scorecard goals for the Product Development Department across all four perspectives.
- Stronger answers
- Detailed, relevant goals under each perspective, grounded in where Cartn stands today.
- Weaker answers
- The same structure as good answers with less detail; more developed points would have lifted them.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Park A recharge: judging the General Manager
(b) Recommend with reasons40% of the task
Core activity E: Stakeholders- What it asked
- How to treat the product under the intellectual capital and social and relationship capital headings of the integrated report.
- Stronger answers
- Detailed disclosures under each heading.
- Weaker answers
- Less detail, where further relevant points would have added marks.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: The treetop trail in the integrated report
Common mistakes
- Summarising the business model instead of testing the proposal against it.
- Discussing both options when asked to recommend one.
- Writing about equity in a sub-task about borrowing.
- Naming a risk framework without the actions it implies.
- Answering for one year when two were asked for.
Lessons for any pre-seen
- A recommendation scores for the choice plus the reasons; giving no clear choice scores neither.
- Circle the scope words in a requirement (debt, two years, three named risks) and cover each.
- Use frameworks as a route to specific actions, not as the answer.
- Adapt generic study points to the case: what is different about this borrower, this asset, this customer?
For the patterns across all 6 variants, read the Cartn examiner's report summary.
Sources
CIMA, Management Case Study, May and August 2026: full post-exam materials (PDF). Page numbers are the PDF's own; each link opens the first page of the range.
- Examiner's report, variant 1: pp199–203
- Suggested answers, variant 1: pp122–133
- Marking guidance, variant 1: pp230–238
- Exam screens, variant 1: pp28–43
The same materials are listed on CIMA's post-exam materials page for May & Aug 2026. Checked on 20 October 2026.
Practise the same skills in Wuudbreak
Timed MCS tasks in the current pre-seen, marked against the same four elements. Try one marked task free, no card needed.
Core is £149 and Premium is £249, one payment per level.