CIMA MCS · May & Aug 2026 · Variant 2
Cartn variant 2 debrief: a faulty batch and a product recall
A faulty batch of Cartn cartons forces a juice maker to recall its product. The exam covers negotiating compensation and accounting for the claims, why quality procedures failed, a new material that removes the aluminium layer, and how to report and drive sustainability.
Updated · Examiner's report pp204–208
- Tasks
- 4
- Sub-tasks
- 8
- Topics
- 6
- Pre-seen
- Cartn
Task 1
Trigger: The customer wants compensation for the cost of the recall and for harm to its reputation.
(a) Recommend with reasons60% of the task
Core activity E: Stakeholders- What it asked
- The approach and main issues in negotiating a settlement with the customer.
- Stronger answers
- Argued for settling quickly and quietly, since the customer would probably accept a fair offer rather than go to court and face publicity; some focused so hard on keeping the customer that they missed the wider reputational risk to Cartn.
- Weaker answers
- Set out a general negotiation process with no link to the case.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Negotiating with a big travel website
(b) Recommend with reasons40% of the task
Core activity D: Measuring performance- What it asked
- The accounting treatment of the claims in the year's financial statements.
- Stronger answers
- Used the provisions standard (IAS 37) and treated the two claims differently: one has no reliable estimate, given a material gap between the parties' figures, so it is a disclosed contingent liability; for the other, the lawyers expect any court action to fail, so the chance of paying is remote and nothing needs to be disclosed. (Had the outflow been possible rather than remote, it would still be a disclosed contingent liability.)
- Weaker answers
- Less accurate, and often gave both claims the same treatment.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Year-end advance payments: the correct accounting
Task 2
Trigger: The Board asks why Cartn's quality procedures did not stop the faulty batch.
(a) Evaluate60% of the task
Core activity C: Performance and costs- What it asked
- The argument that Cartn cannot claim to have followed TQM on this order.
- Stronger answers
- Pointed to the missing shift handover procedure and undocumented machine problems as signs of weak commitment, and said what should have happened, such as checking early output after a stoppage.
- Weaker answers
- Generic TQM theory, or a conclusion either way without justification.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Inclusive break: can it meet its target cost?
(b) Identify and evaluate40% of the task
Core activity B: Implementing decisions- What it asked
- The difficulties of setting effective performance measures for the quality department.
- Stronger answers
- Evaluated problems such as how hard failures are to track, the need for indirect measures like training, and checking whether a failure was Cartn's or the customer's.
- Weaker answers
- Recommended measures instead of discussing why they are hard to set.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Park A recharge: judging the General Manager
Task 3
Trigger: Cartn has a new process that removes the need for an aluminium layer in its cartons.
(a) Identify and evaluate60% of the task
Core activity A: Adding value- What it asked
- The difficulties of predicting the cash flows from developing and making the new material.
- Stronger answers
- Reasoned through customer reluctance to switch, manufacturing costs that depend on a steady fibre supply, and suppliers' power once Cartn depends on them.
- Weaker answers
- Wrote about NPV in general, such as how to set a discount rate.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Saplings or mature trees for the conifer forests?
(b) Recommend with reasons40% of the task
Core activity B: Implementing decisions- What it asked
- The real options the Board should consider in evaluating the investment.
- Stronger answers
- Justified concrete options, such as converting a few factories to begin with or keeping removed equipment so the change can be reversed.
- Weaker answers
- Did not show what a real option is.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Saplings or mature trees for the conifer forests?
Task 4
Trigger: The Board wants advice on managing and reporting sustainability.
(a) Explain60% of the task
Core activity D: Measuring performance- What it asked
- Whether the sustainability report may stress the green benefits of a product developed mainly to raise profit.
- Stronger answers
- Saw the nuance: sustainability reports give facts from which stakeholders draw their own conclusions, directors may stress genuine benefits as long as nothing misleads, and profit and sustainability often go together.
- Weaker answers
- A brief, firm no without justification.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Climate disclosures: what the standards require
(b) Recommend with reasons40% of the task
Core activity C: Performance and costs- What it asked
- Performance indicators that would push R&D to build sustainability into future products and processes.
- Stronger answers
- Chose and justified indicators such as the share of new initiatives that improve sustainability, noting that good data may arrive late in development.
- Weaker answers
- Listed indicators without asking whether they suit R&D or the case.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Measuring Fernside as an investment centre
Common mistakes
- Giving every claim the same accounting treatment.
- Recommending measures when the sub-task asked about the difficulties of setting them.
- Explaining NPV mechanics instead of why the cash flows are hard to predict.
- A one-word ethical verdict with no reasoning.
Lessons for any pre-seen
- Split a claim or event into its elements and treat each one under the standard.
- Difficulties, challenges and problems are requirements in their own right; answer them, not the solution.
- Questions about acceptability reward balance: the argument, the counter-argument, then a reasoned view.
- A real option is a concrete choice the company keeps open; name it and say why it helps.
For the patterns across all 6 variants, read the Cartn examiner's report summary.
Sources
CIMA, Management Case Study, May and August 2026: full post-exam materials (PDF). Page numbers are the PDF's own; each link opens the first page of the range.
- Examiner's report, variant 2: pp204–208
- Suggested answers, variant 2: pp134–144
- Marking guidance, variant 2: pp240–248
- Exam screens, variant 2: pp44–59
The same materials are listed on CIMA's post-exam materials page for May & Aug 2026. Checked on 20 October 2026.
Practise the same skills in Wuudbreak
Timed MCS tasks in the current pre-seen, marked against the same four elements. Try one marked task free, no card needed.
Core is £149 and Premium is £249, one payment per level.