CIMA MCS · May & Aug 2026 · Variant 3
Cartn variant 3 debrief: designing and building a client's factory
Cartn's consultancy arm proposes to oversee the design and building of a factory for a client, Luxsoup, with equipment from another maker and Cartn's own factory engineers doing the installation. The exam covers setting up the project, pricing the service, risk and the cost of capital, seconding staff, revenue recognition and quality.
Updated · Examiner's report pp209–213
- Tasks
- 4
- Sub-tasks
- 8
- Topics
- 8
- Pre-seen
- Cartn
Task 1
Trigger: The Board is considering how to start investigating a proposal to extend the consultancy service.
(a) Recommend with reasons60% of the task
Core activity B: Implementing decisions- What it asked
- The steps to set up a project team to evaluate the proposal.
- Stronger answers
- Set the scope and boundaries (budget, objectives, timescale, members' time and roles), with reporting lines and goals clear enough to decide whether to proceed.
- Weaker answers
- Basic team theory and role types, options rather than recommendations, or how the team would carry out the project rather than evaluate it.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Booking system project: getting it back under control
(b) Recommend with reasons40% of the task
Core activity A: Adding value- What it asked
- A pricing strategy for the revised consultancy service.
- Stronger answers
- Argued for bundling with existing consultancy and premium pricing, while watching how competitors respond and adjusting as the market develops.
- Weaker answers
- Listed pricing types, sometimes contradictory, without reasons.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Should dynamic pricing go to every park?
Task 2
Trigger: The Board is worried about the risks of offering the client a full service package.
(a) Identify and evaluate40% of the task
Core activity D: Measuring performance- What it asked
- The operational and contractual inadequacy risks of the full service.
- Stronger answers
- Spotted that both teams could lack the skills needed and must co-ordinate tightly, and the need to document steps and responsibilities to close contractual gaps.
- Weaker answers
- Said the project might fail or be late without saying why, and missed the gaps in a three-way arrangement between the equipment maker, the client's removal team and Cartn's installers.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: What the Hub closure tells us about risk
(b) Evaluate60% of the task
Core activity A: Adding value- What it asked
- Whether announcing the contract win would raise or lower Cartn's weighted average cost of capital.
- Stronger answers
- Concluded the effect is small and favourable, given low gearing, better cash flow and no new investment, working through debt, equity and the weightings.
- Weaker answers
- Asserted a direction with little or no reasoning.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Is 9% still the right discount rate?
Task 3
Trigger: The contract is signed, and factory maintenance engineers will be seconded to the consultancy department.
(a) Identify and evaluate60% of the task
Core activity E: Stakeholders- What it asked
- The challenges of setting transfer prices for the secondments so they serve Cartn as a whole.
- Stronger answers
- Saw that two profit-measured departments will pull against each other, that the opportunity cost depends on how much maintenance is needed at the time, and that the installation team needs to be settled.
- Weaker answers
- Generic transfer pricing theory and assertions without reasoning.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Charging the parks for Kitchen Hub dishes
(b) Recommend with reasons40% of the task
Core activity C: Performance and costs- What it asked
- How to manage the motivation and engagement of the seconded factory staff.
- Stronger answers
- Early consultation and direct two-way communication to gain buy-in, surface concerns and act on them.
- Weaker answers
- A list of incentives, with staff told rather than consulted.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Giving park managers a say in pricing
Task 4
Trigger: The contract is under way.
(a) Recommend with reasons40% of the task
Core activity D: Measuring performance- What it asked
- The accounting treatment of the contract's revenue across two financial years.
- Stronger answers
- Applied the revenue standard (IFRS 15): identify the performance obligations, recognise revenue as they are met, and treat the retention as conditional on there being no defects.
- Weaker answers
- Very brief or missing, with revenue split between years without justification.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Year-end advance payments: the correct accounting
(b) Recommend with reasons60% of the task
Core activity C: Performance and costs- What it asked
- How the ideas behind TQM could be built into Cartn's work on the client's equipment.
- Stronger answers
- Gave reasoned, prioritised steps in a sensible order (skills and training, documentation, inspection and testing), and fed lessons into continuous improvement.
- Weaker answers
- A short list without reasons or sequence, or TQM theory with no link to the case.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Inclusive break: can it meet its target cost?
Common mistakes
- Describing how a project team would deliver a project when the task was to set one up to evaluate a proposal.
- Risk answers that say a project might fail without naming a cause.
- Asserting the direction of a change in the cost of capital without reasoning.
- Motivation answers built on incentives and instructions, not consultation.
Lessons for any pre-seen
- Check the stage of the project the task is at: evaluating a proposal is not delivering it.
- A risk is a cause and an effect; name both.
- For WACC questions, work through the cost of debt, the cost of equity and the weightings in turn.
- When a contract involves several parties, look for the gaps between them.
For the patterns across all 6 variants, read the Cartn examiner's report summary.
Sources
CIMA, Management Case Study, May and August 2026: full post-exam materials (PDF). Page numbers are the PDF's own; each link opens the first page of the range.
- Examiner's report, variant 3: pp209–213
- Suggested answers, variant 3: pp146–157
- Marking guidance, variant 3: pp250–258
- Exam screens, variant 3: pp60–74
The same materials are listed on CIMA's post-exam materials page for May & Aug 2026. Checked on 20 October 2026.
Practise the same skills in Wuudbreak
Timed MCS tasks in the current pre-seen, marked against the same four elements. Try one marked task free, no card needed.
Core is £149 and Premium is £249, one payment per level.