CIMA MCS · May & Aug 2026 · Variant 4
Cartn variant 4 debrief: hot-meal tubs for fast food chains
Cartn develops tubs that let fast food restaurants serve hot, saucy dishes. The exam covers fit with the business model, stress testing demand, buying a design company and keeping its founder, re-engineering production for a restaurant chain, then scald claims and internal pricing.
Updated · Examiner's report pp214–218
- Tasks
- 4
- Sub-tasks
- 8
- Topics
- 7
- Pre-seen
- Cartn
Task 1
Trigger: The Board plans new containers, designed with fast food chains, so the chains can add hot dishes to their menus.
(a) Evaluate60% of the task
Core activity A: Adding value- What it asked
- The argument that working with fast food chains on the tubs is consistent with Cartn's business model.
- Stronger answers
- Linked specific parts of Cartn's model to the proposal and picked out the parts most affected.
- Weaker answers
- Described the existing business model with little sense of the commercial implications.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: All-inclusive trend: fit with our business model
(b) Evaluate40% of the task
Core activity D: Measuring performance- What it asked
- How useful it is to stress test the chains' exposure to consumers' finances when predicting demand for the tubs.
- Stronger answers
- Weighed the usefulness of the results, with attention to consumer demand for fast food and Cartn's reliance on the chains for revenue.
- Weaker answers
- Gave examples of stress tests without assessing how useful the results would be.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: What the Hub closure tells us about risk
Task 2
Trigger: Cartn could buy a business that already holds the right designs, and its founder has requests about her future role.
(a) Identify and evaluate60% of the task
Core activity E: Stakeholders- What it asked
- The difficulties of measuring the goodwill that would arise on the acquisition.
- Stronger answers
- Saw that Cartn must fair value the target's net assets, and picked out the hard ones, such as patents and buildings.
- Weaker answers
- Talked about valuing the target itself, missing that goodwill is the consideration less the fair value of the net assets.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: How Fernside will appear in the group accounts
(b) Identify and evaluate40% of the task
Core activity B: Implementing decisions- What it asked
- The conflicts that could follow from granting the founder's requests.
- Stronger answers
- Used the exhibit: the founder's motives and the risk of demotivating Cartn's own designers.
- Weaker answers
- Ignored the specific requests and what they would mean for Cartn.
Task 3
Trigger: Customers are testing the early designs, and a supply deal with a restaurant chain is taking shape.
(a) Recommend with reasons60% of the task
Core activity C: Performance and costs- What it asked
- The work Cartn should do to re-engineer production to make the new tubs for the chain.
- Stronger answers
- Covered what must change to mass produce the tubs, in the machinery and in the work of the staff who run it.
- Weaker answers
- Did not see the need for re-engineering or what the term means.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Inclusive break: can it meet its target cost?
(b) Evaluate and recommend with reasons40% of the task
Core activity B: Implementing decisions- What it asked
- The contractual inadequacy risks of supplying the chain, and how to reduce them.
- Stronger answers
- Started from the likely contract terms and built arguments on how they could be breached, for example through the tub's design.
- Weaker answers
- Missed that the contract might not cover areas such as quality or delivery, which is the heart of contractual inadequacy.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Watersports centre: reducing the risk
Task 4
Trigger: Diners at some restaurants say hot food in the new containers burned them.
(a) Recommend with reasons60% of the task
Core activity D: Measuring performance- What it asked
- The accounting treatment of the claims against Cartn and of a payment it has agreed to make.
- Stronger answers
- Took each element of the claims separately and treated each correctly under the provisions standard (IAS 37).
- Weaker answers
- Lumped the elements together and so failed to apply the standard.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Year-end advance payments: the correct accounting
(b) Identify and evaluate40% of the task
Core activity E: Stakeholders- What it asked
- The difficulties of setting transfer prices for the tubs that encourage internal sales good for Cartn as a whole.
- Stronger answers
- Identified what would lead to dysfunctional behaviour and evaluated how far it could be overcome.
- Weaker answers
- Described the dysfunction, such as useful stock left unsold, without explaining why it would happen.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Charging the parks for Kitchen Hub dishes
Common mistakes
- Describing the business model instead of evaluating the proposal against it.
- Listing stress test scenarios without judging how useful they are.
- Confusing the value of the target with the goodwill on acquiring it.
- Combining separate claims into one accounting treatment.
Lessons for any pre-seen
- Evaluate the usefulness of a technique means weighing what its results can and cannot tell you.
- Goodwill is a difference: the price paid against the fair value of what is acquired.
- Read the exhibit for people's motives; conflicts come from them.
- Contractual inadequacy is about what the contract fails to cover; look for the gaps.
For the patterns across all 6 variants, read the Cartn examiner's report summary.
Sources
CIMA, Management Case Study, May and August 2026: full post-exam materials (PDF). Page numbers are the PDF's own; each link opens the first page of the range.
- Examiner's report, variant 4: pp214–218
- Suggested answers, variant 4: pp158–169
- Marking guidance, variant 4: pp260–268
- Exam screens, variant 4: pp75–91
The same materials are listed on CIMA's post-exam materials page for May & Aug 2026. Checked on 20 October 2026.
Practise the same skills in Wuudbreak
Timed MCS tasks in the current pre-seen, marked against the same four elements. Try one marked task free, no card needed.
Core is £149 and Premium is £249, one payment per level.