Skip to content

CIMA MCS · May & Aug 2026 · Variant 4

Cartn variant 4 debrief: hot-meal tubs for fast food chains

Cartn develops tubs that let fast food restaurants serve hot, saucy dishes. The exam covers fit with the business model, stress testing demand, buying a design company and keeping its founder, re-engineering production for a restaurant chain, then scald claims and internal pricing.

Updated · Examiner's report pp214–218

Tasks
4
Sub-tasks
8
Topics
7
Pre-seen
Cartn

Task 1

Trigger: The Board plans new containers, designed with fast food chains, so the chains can add hot dishes to their menus.

  1. (a) Evaluate60% of the task

    Core activity A: Adding value
    What it asked
    The argument that working with fast food chains on the tubs is consistent with Cartn's business model.
    Stronger answers
    Linked specific parts of Cartn's model to the proposal and picked out the parts most affected.
    Weaker answers
    Described the existing business model with little sense of the commercial implications.
    Practise it in Wuudbreak: All-inclusive trend: fit with our business model
  2. (b) Evaluate40% of the task

    Core activity D: Measuring performance
    What it asked
    How useful it is to stress test the chains' exposure to consumers' finances when predicting demand for the tubs.
    Stronger answers
    Weighed the usefulness of the results, with attention to consumer demand for fast food and Cartn's reliance on the chains for revenue.
    Weaker answers
    Gave examples of stress tests without assessing how useful the results would be.
    Practise it in Wuudbreak: What the Hub closure tells us about risk

Task 2

Trigger: Cartn could buy a business that already holds the right designs, and its founder has requests about her future role.

  1. (a) Identify and evaluate60% of the task

    Core activity E: Stakeholders
    What it asked
    The difficulties of measuring the goodwill that would arise on the acquisition.
    Stronger answers
    Saw that Cartn must fair value the target's net assets, and picked out the hard ones, such as patents and buildings.
    Weaker answers
    Talked about valuing the target itself, missing that goodwill is the consideration less the fair value of the net assets.
    Practise it in Wuudbreak: How Fernside will appear in the group accounts
  2. (b) Identify and evaluate40% of the task

    Core activity B: Implementing decisions
    What it asked
    The conflicts that could follow from granting the founder's requests.
    Stronger answers
    Used the exhibit: the founder's motives and the risk of demotivating Cartn's own designers.
    Weaker answers
    Ignored the specific requests and what they would mean for Cartn.

Task 3

Trigger: Customers are testing the early designs, and a supply deal with a restaurant chain is taking shape.

  1. (a) Recommend with reasons60% of the task

    Core activity C: Performance and costs
    What it asked
    The work Cartn should do to re-engineer production to make the new tubs for the chain.
    Stronger answers
    Covered what must change to mass produce the tubs, in the machinery and in the work of the staff who run it.
    Weaker answers
    Did not see the need for re-engineering or what the term means.
    Practise it in Wuudbreak: Inclusive break: can it meet its target cost?
  2. (b) Evaluate and recommend with reasons40% of the task

    Core activity B: Implementing decisions
    What it asked
    The contractual inadequacy risks of supplying the chain, and how to reduce them.
    Stronger answers
    Started from the likely contract terms and built arguments on how they could be breached, for example through the tub's design.
    Weaker answers
    Missed that the contract might not cover areas such as quality or delivery, which is the heart of contractual inadequacy.
    Practise it in Wuudbreak: Watersports centre: reducing the risk

Task 4

Trigger: Diners at some restaurants say hot food in the new containers burned them.

  1. (a) Recommend with reasons60% of the task

    Core activity D: Measuring performance
    What it asked
    The accounting treatment of the claims against Cartn and of a payment it has agreed to make.
    Stronger answers
    Took each element of the claims separately and treated each correctly under the provisions standard (IAS 37).
    Weaker answers
    Lumped the elements together and so failed to apply the standard.
    Practise it in Wuudbreak: Year-end advance payments: the correct accounting
  2. (b) Identify and evaluate40% of the task

    Core activity E: Stakeholders
    What it asked
    The difficulties of setting transfer prices for the tubs that encourage internal sales good for Cartn as a whole.
    Stronger answers
    Identified what would lead to dysfunctional behaviour and evaluated how far it could be overcome.
    Weaker answers
    Described the dysfunction, such as useful stock left unsold, without explaining why it would happen.
    Practise it in Wuudbreak: Charging the parks for Kitchen Hub dishes

Common mistakes

  • Describing the business model instead of evaluating the proposal against it.
  • Listing stress test scenarios without judging how useful they are.
  • Confusing the value of the target with the goodwill on acquiring it.
  • Combining separate claims into one accounting treatment.

Lessons for any pre-seen

  • Evaluate the usefulness of a technique means weighing what its results can and cannot tell you.
  • Goodwill is a difference: the price paid against the fair value of what is acquired.
  • Read the exhibit for people's motives; conflicts come from them.
  • Contractual inadequacy is about what the contract fails to cover; look for the gaps.

For the patterns across all 6 variants, read the Cartn examiner's report summary.

Sources

CIMA, Management Case Study, May and August 2026: full post-exam materials (PDF). Page numbers are the PDF's own; each link opens the first page of the range.

The same materials are listed on CIMA's post-exam materials page for May & Aug 2026. Checked on 20 October 2026.

Practise the same skills in Wuudbreak

Timed MCS tasks in the current pre-seen, marked against the same four elements. Try one marked task free, no card needed.

Core is £149 and Premium is £249, one payment per level.

Not ready to try a task? Tell us why. One question, no email.
What would stop you?