Skip to content

CIMA MCS · May & Aug 2026 · Variant 5

Cartn variant 5 debrief: carton recycling centres

Cartn considers building recycling centres for used cartons, then sells recovered plastic through a joint venture with a furniture maker. The exam covers stakeholders and NPV challenges, project constraints and target costing, joint venture risks and accounting, then reporting and pricing the recovered material.

Updated · Examiner's report pp219–223

Tasks
4
Sub-tasks
8
Topics
8
Pre-seen
Cartn

Task 1

Trigger: Cartn is considering setting up plants to recycle used cartons.

  1. (a) Identify and evaluate60% of the task

    Core activity A: Adding value
    What it asked
    The three main stakeholders in the decision and the challenges of understanding their interests.
    Stronger answers
    Chose three distinct stakeholders and focused on why their interests are hard to read, not on why they matter.
    Weaker answers
    Chose three similar stakeholders, such as three directors, and described them.
    Practise it in Wuudbreak: Is the treetop trail appraisal fit for the board?
  2. (b) Evaluate40% of the task

    Core activity B: Implementing decisions
    What it asked
    The challenges of judging whether the recycling centres would have a positive NPV.
    Stronger answers
    Picked the inputs that are hard to pin down, such as how many usable cartons will be recovered and whether local councils might pull out.
    Weaker answers
    Described the steps of an NPV calculation.
    Practise it in Wuudbreak: Saplings or mature trees for the conifer forests?

Task 2

Trigger: The Board decides to go ahead and sets up a project team.

  1. (a) Evaluate40% of the task

    Core activity B: Implementing decisions
    What it asked
    The impact of the time, cost and quality constraints the Board should set for the team.
    Stronger answers
    Evaluated each constraint and the links between them, such as reputational harm if poor-quality output ends in landfill and time pressure from possible bans on cartons.
    Weaker answers
    Gave a general account of the three constraints.
    Practise it in Wuudbreak: Booking system project: getting it back under control
  2. (b) Recommend with reasons60% of the task

    Core activity C: Performance and costs
    What it asked
    How the project team should use target costing in deciding on the recycling centres.
    Stronger answers
    Gave specific advice linking the investment to running costs, the recovery rate Cartn needs to keep its good name, and how what it pays relates to what it recovers.
    Weaker answers
    Described target costing without applying it to this decision.
    Practise it in Wuudbreak: Inclusive break: can it meet its target cost?

Task 3

Trigger: Business risks worry the Board, and Cartn has formed a joint venture with a buyer of recovered plastic, which will turn it into office furniture.

  1. (a) Advise60% of the task

    Core activity D: Measuring performance
    What it asked
    The risk of poor demand for the furniture, the operational risk of Cartn's role in the venture and the risk that the agreement does not cover every outcome.
    Stronger answers
    Took all three risks in turn: what each is, its likely impact and how to address it.
    Weaker answers
    Covered one or two of the three, without enough depth to guide the Board.
    Practise it in Wuudbreak: What the Hub closure tells us about risk
  2. (b) Recommend40% of the task

    Core activity E: Stakeholders
    What it asked
    The accounting treatment of Cartn's investment in the joint venture and its early trading.
    Stronger answers
    Applied the equity method and explained how it appears in the group accounts.
    Weaker answers
    Poor technical knowledge, for example treating the joint venture as a subsidiary.
    Practise it in Wuudbreak: How Fernside will appear in the group accounts

Task 4

Trigger: The product has been launched.

  1. (a) Recommend with reasons60% of the task

    Core activity E: Stakeholders
    What it asked
    How to report sales of recovered plastic under manufactured, social and relationship, and natural capital in the integrated report.
    Stronger answers
    Specific recommendations under each capital: the recycling centres' capabilities, relationships with buyers, and diverting waste from landfill.
    Weaker answers
    Misunderstood the capitals, for example treating manufactured capital as equity.
    Practise it in Wuudbreak: The treetop trail in the integrated report
  2. (b) Recommend with reasons40% of the task

    Core activity A: Adding value
    What it asked
    A pricing strategy for the recovered plastic.
    Stronger answers
    Reasoned from the absence of a direct rival, the margin needed above cost and the value of keeping new entrants out.
    Weaker answers
    Listed pricing methods and picked one without reasons.
    Practise it in Wuudbreak: Should dynamic pricing go to every park?

Common mistakes

  • Choosing three near-identical stakeholders.
  • Describing how to calculate an NPV instead of what makes this one hard.
  • Covering some of the risks the sub-task named.
  • Treating a joint venture as a subsidiary.
  • Mixing up the integrated reporting capitals.

Lessons for any pre-seen

  • When a task asks for a number of items, choose distinct ones that give you different things to say.
  • Challenges questions want the case-specific uncertainties, not the method.
  • If the requirement names three risks, give each one its own heading.
  • Learn the six capitals precisely enough to place a real item under each.

For the patterns across all 6 variants, read the Cartn examiner's report summary.

Sources

CIMA, Management Case Study, May and August 2026: full post-exam materials (PDF). Page numbers are the PDF's own; each link opens the first page of the range.

The same materials are listed on CIMA's post-exam materials page for May & Aug 2026. Checked on 20 October 2026.

Practise the same skills in Wuudbreak

Timed MCS tasks in the current pre-seen, marked against the same four elements. Try one marked task free, no card needed.

Core is £149 and Premium is £249, one payment per level.

Not ready to try a task? Tell us why. One question, no email.
What would stop you?