CIMA MCS · May & Aug 2026 · Variant 5
Cartn variant 5 debrief: carton recycling centres
Cartn considers building recycling centres for used cartons, then sells recovered plastic through a joint venture with a furniture maker. The exam covers stakeholders and NPV challenges, project constraints and target costing, joint venture risks and accounting, then reporting and pricing the recovered material.
Updated · Examiner's report pp219–223
- Tasks
- 4
- Sub-tasks
- 8
- Topics
- 8
- Pre-seen
- Cartn
Task 1
Trigger: Cartn is considering setting up plants to recycle used cartons.
(a) Identify and evaluate60% of the task
Core activity A: Adding value- What it asked
- The three main stakeholders in the decision and the challenges of understanding their interests.
- Stronger answers
- Chose three distinct stakeholders and focused on why their interests are hard to read, not on why they matter.
- Weaker answers
- Chose three similar stakeholders, such as three directors, and described them.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Is the treetop trail appraisal fit for the board?
(b) Evaluate40% of the task
Core activity B: Implementing decisions- What it asked
- The challenges of judging whether the recycling centres would have a positive NPV.
- Stronger answers
- Picked the inputs that are hard to pin down, such as how many usable cartons will be recovered and whether local councils might pull out.
- Weaker answers
- Described the steps of an NPV calculation.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Saplings or mature trees for the conifer forests?
Task 2
Trigger: The Board decides to go ahead and sets up a project team.
(a) Evaluate40% of the task
Core activity B: Implementing decisions- What it asked
- The impact of the time, cost and quality constraints the Board should set for the team.
- Stronger answers
- Evaluated each constraint and the links between them, such as reputational harm if poor-quality output ends in landfill and time pressure from possible bans on cartons.
- Weaker answers
- Gave a general account of the three constraints.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Booking system project: getting it back under control
(b) Recommend with reasons60% of the task
Core activity C: Performance and costs- What it asked
- How the project team should use target costing in deciding on the recycling centres.
- Stronger answers
- Gave specific advice linking the investment to running costs, the recovery rate Cartn needs to keep its good name, and how what it pays relates to what it recovers.
- Weaker answers
- Described target costing without applying it to this decision.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Inclusive break: can it meet its target cost?
Task 3
Trigger: Business risks worry the Board, and Cartn has formed a joint venture with a buyer of recovered plastic, which will turn it into office furniture.
(a) Advise60% of the task
Core activity D: Measuring performance- What it asked
- The risk of poor demand for the furniture, the operational risk of Cartn's role in the venture and the risk that the agreement does not cover every outcome.
- Stronger answers
- Took all three risks in turn: what each is, its likely impact and how to address it.
- Weaker answers
- Covered one or two of the three, without enough depth to guide the Board.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: What the Hub closure tells us about risk
(b) Recommend40% of the task
Core activity E: Stakeholders- What it asked
- The accounting treatment of Cartn's investment in the joint venture and its early trading.
- Stronger answers
- Applied the equity method and explained how it appears in the group accounts.
- Weaker answers
- Poor technical knowledge, for example treating the joint venture as a subsidiary.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: How Fernside will appear in the group accounts
Task 4
Trigger: The product has been launched.
(a) Recommend with reasons60% of the task
Core activity E: Stakeholders- What it asked
- How to report sales of recovered plastic under manufactured, social and relationship, and natural capital in the integrated report.
- Stronger answers
- Specific recommendations under each capital: the recycling centres' capabilities, relationships with buyers, and diverting waste from landfill.
- Weaker answers
- Misunderstood the capitals, for example treating manufactured capital as equity.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: The treetop trail in the integrated report
(b) Recommend with reasons40% of the task
Core activity A: Adding value- What it asked
- A pricing strategy for the recovered plastic.
- Stronger answers
- Reasoned from the absence of a direct rival, the margin needed above cost and the value of keeping new entrants out.
- Weaker answers
- Listed pricing methods and picked one without reasons.
- Practise it in Wuudbreak: Should dynamic pricing go to every park?
Common mistakes
- Choosing three near-identical stakeholders.
- Describing how to calculate an NPV instead of what makes this one hard.
- Covering some of the risks the sub-task named.
- Treating a joint venture as a subsidiary.
- Mixing up the integrated reporting capitals.
Lessons for any pre-seen
- When a task asks for a number of items, choose distinct ones that give you different things to say.
- Challenges questions want the case-specific uncertainties, not the method.
- If the requirement names three risks, give each one its own heading.
- Learn the six capitals precisely enough to place a real item under each.
For the patterns across all 6 variants, read the Cartn examiner's report summary.
Sources
CIMA, Management Case Study, May and August 2026: full post-exam materials (PDF). Page numbers are the PDF's own; each link opens the first page of the range.
- Examiner's report, variant 5: pp219–223
- Suggested answers, variant 5: pp170–181
- Marking guidance, variant 5: pp270–278
- Exam screens, variant 5: pp92–106
The same materials are listed on CIMA's post-exam materials page for May & Aug 2026. Checked on 20 October 2026.
Practise the same skills in Wuudbreak
Timed MCS tasks in the current pre-seen, marked against the same four elements. Try one marked task free, no card needed.
Core is £149 and Premium is £249, one payment per level.